CHINA-INTERNAL: PROPAGANDA CONTROLS, INTERNET & IDEOLOGY

The June 23, 2017, issue of the Party theoretical journal Qiushi (Seeking Truth) published an article entitled “The U.S.’s Strategy of Exporting Ideology over the Internet will not change” by Li Yanyan, a Deputy Professor at the Marxism Institute, Beijing Technology Institute and a Postdoctoral candidate at the Institute of Philosophy, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. The Qiushi article discussed how the US exports ideology over the Internet and that this had become a core part of the US ’strategy of “public diplomacy.”

The article includes the following important points:

i) Exporting ideology is an important part of the US government’s strategic public diplomacy. According to the group that set up the US newspolicy in 1997, the U.S public diplomacy strategy advances US national interest through the use of understanding, and through increasing and furthering its influence over the public in foreign countries. John E. Reinhardt, former Director of the U.S. International Communication Agency, pointed out, the nature of strategic public diplomacy is the activity in which the “U.S. government enters into the international ideology market.” The core of strategic public diplomacy is exporting ideology.

ii) During the Cold War, U.S. government actively carried out its public diplomacy on a large scale. It conducted one-directional information dissemination to the former Soviet Union, took over control of its domestic opinion, and successfully destroyed its people’s confidence in their own development path and their political system. The ideology campaign played a very important role in helping the US to win the Cold War. The success of the psychological warfare made this once mighty superpower collapse under the collective silence of its people.

iii) Public diplomacy, as the core of a country’s strategic foreign policy, often adopts the media to target the concerned country. Today, the US has superior advantages in Internet technology and management and a strategic advantage in exporting its ideology. Just like the relationship of computer software and hardware, public diplomacy, which has the goal of controlling the public mind, has worked along with the Internet. Together, they leverage each other’s power. It has thus enabled the US to play a decisive role in guiding the world’s ideology and opinions.

iv) At the end of the 20th century, the US exported its ideology mainly through the US Information Agency. This was the first stage of the US exporting its ideology over the Internet, but the US only used the Internet to collect, transmit, and publish information. Its huge social and political impact had not yet been fully displayed.

v) The second stage started when the U.S. government officially endorsed exporting its ideology over the Internet. In 2001, after the U.S. suffered the 9/11 terror attack, everyone was pondering, “Why did the world hate the U.S?” People quickly attributed (this attitude) to a lack of effort in US public diplomacy and, therefore public diplomacy policy gained unprecedented attention. Public diplomacy and Internet diplomacy merged together and the US ideology was presented to the world through Internet media such as government, business and newswebsites.

vi) In the third stage the US used social media to export its ideology, coinciding with the emergence and unprecedented growth of Blog, Facebook, Twitter, and other social networks. The way the US exports its ideology also changed. An article in the Deutsche Welle published on April 7, 2011, titled, “VOA: The Internet Is the Main Channel through which to Reach the Chinese Public,” predicted that the US would “focus on the digital front to export its ideology to China.” 

vii) In recent years, the US has used the Internet to accelerate building of its influence in China to move it toward democracy. The US has launched a campaign of public opinion, shifted the political-based discourse towards public opinion-based discourse, and established a system for (the Chinese public) to recognize US political values.

viii) As globalization has progressed, the U.S. government has devoted efforts for public diplomacy to adapt to the transformation of the information culture. It is building a new  building a future diplomacy model that is “decentralized with flat management.” Therefore exporting ideology towards multiple centers and over multiple levels has become an important strategic task for the US government.  The Obama administration called the new approach, which uses the Internet and new media technology to export ideology, Public Diplomacy 2.0. Its goal was to spread the US voice around the world.

ix) The Internet that uses social media has become an important ideology battleground both domestically and internationally.  There are indications that China has become the main global target for the US to export its ideology. Recent frequent ideology and media exchanges on the Internet suggest that the US government has used stock buyouts and training of spokespersons to control our Internet platform. Its intention to guide the media has become increasingly obvious, resulting "in a serious threat to the security of our ideology".

x) "From the development of the ideology battle that the anti-China hostile forces incited, one can see that the enemy on ideology over the Internet has taken shape. It consists of a foreign command center, domestic bases, social celebrities, and an “Internet water Army” (paid online commentators). Through Internet media channels, the US anti-China forces and their representatives have taken advantage of Internet information fragmentation. They have selectively used the rich and long Chinese history while ignoring the great achievements made in China today. They have tried to incite a separation between the (Communist) Party and its people and have become the key troublemaker for the worsened relationship between the Party and the public. Moreover, the US, via the use of Internet media, hoped to form pro-U.S. social organizations in China and develop them into a political force that represents the US political interests to further influence China in its political advancement and social development".

xi) The US has been able to spread its ideology rapidly over the Chinese Internet and has even tried to guide the media discourse.The way it worked was, “We will not force you to do anything, but we will plant (our ideology) in your heart, enter into your sub-conscience, and eventually make you do something.”

xii) The US strategy of exporting ideology has entered maturity and gained tremendous economic and political interest. Some US officials have directly pointed out that “the decisive factors that will determine the fate and future of U.S. capitalism are not through military force but through ideology.” “For socialist countries to jump into the arms of the West, it all starts with the Internet.”

xiii) Exporting ideology over the Internet has become an important strategy for the U.S. government.

(Comment: This article is the result of a research project that the China’s Postdoctoral Science Foundation and the Individual Projects of the Beijing Young Talent Development Program funded.)







Subscribe to Newswire | Site Map | Email Us
Centre for China Analysis and Strategy, A-50, Second Floor, Vasant Vihar, New Delhi-110057
Tel: 011 41017353
Email: office@ccasindia.org